Your third-party administrator (TPA) provides an important service by administering claims on your organization’s behalf. Depending on your agreement, its responsibilities may include investigating claims, coordinating benefits and payments, managing reserves, and supporting claim resolution.
Many TPAs also offer reporting portals, analytics, and additional services such as medical case management, return-to-work support, safety consulting, or a full Risk Management Information System (RMIS). The scope varies by administrator and service agreement.
So why would an employer, city, county, or risk pool consider maintaining its own RMIS?
Even when a TPA offers these capabilities, an organization may benefit from maintaining its own RMIS. The value lies in bringing information from TPAs and internal operations together in a system the organization controls, supporting its own workflows and preserving a consistent history across changes in administrators.
An organization-controlled RMIS can complement your TPA’s services while supporting your broader risk management needs.
Connecting Claims, Safety, and Case Management
A workers’ compensation claim can raise questions about employee safety, lost workdays, staffing, and return-to-work opportunities. A vehicle accident may reveal concerns involving driver training, equipment, or a particular location. A liability claim may point to a recurring facility hazard.
An organization-controlled RMIS can connect the TPA’s claims and case management information with internal safety investigations, inspections, corrective actions, and return-to-work coordination. With appropriate access controls, designated staff can work from consistent information while protecting sensitive records
For example, a claim may show the cost of a back injury. The investigation may identify a lifting hazard. Case management records may document work restrictions and return-to-work progress.
Together, those records provide a clearer picture of what happened, how the organization responded, and where prevention efforts may help.
Using consistent employee, department, and location information across these activities can also reduce conflicting records and improve reporting.
Looking Beyond the Claims Your TPA Handles
Your organization’s risk picture extends beyond the claims administered by your TPA.
Near misses, safety concerns, minor property damage, and certain internally handled losses may not appear in the administrator’s records. Yet these events can reveal recurring problems before they result in a larger loss.
Organizations with high deductibles or self-insured retentions may also need to track costs and activity they manage directly. Reporting responsibilities still depend on the policy and claims-handling agreement; a loss below the deductible may still require reporting.
An internal RMIS can bring these records together with TPA claims data. That broader history helps organizations evaluate the frequency and cumulative cost of smaller events alongside their more significant claims.
For example, repeated minor vehicle damage at one location may deserve attention even if few of those incidents appear in the TPA’s reports.
The result is a more complete view of organizational risk—not just the claims that make it into the administrator’s system.
Using Historical Data to Make Better Decisions
Historical information becomes more valuable when it helps guide action.
Dashboards, trend analysis, and comparisons across departments, locations, and years can help risk managers investigate questions such as:
- Where are similar injuries or incidents recurring?
- Are costs increasing because there are more claims, more expensive claims, or both?
- Which departments experience reporting delays?
- How do lost workdays and return-to-work outcomes vary?
- Are incidents recurring after corrective actions are completed?
Meaningful comparisons also need context. A department with more employees, vehicles, or operating hours may naturally have more incidents. Evaluating losses relative to those exposures can provide a more useful comparison than claim counts alone.
Predictive analytics and artificial intelligence can extend this work by highlighting patterns, identifying unusual activity, and flagging claims or conditions that may warrant closer review.
Their usefulness depends on the quality, completeness, and relevance of the underlying data. Risk professionals must review the findings, consider operational context, and decide what action is appropriate. An identified pattern is a reason to investigate, not proof of a cause or a guarantee of future outcomes.
The goal is to use what happened in the past to make better decisions about where to focus attention and resources next.
Maintaining Your Own Record of Risk Information
Receiving claims data from TPAs is a common RMIS workflow. Information may be transferred through scheduled files, integrations, or other agreed processes.
Maintaining that information in an organization-controlled system provides a consistent source for reporting and historical reference. It also helps preserve access to important information when a portal is unavailable, a service relationship changes, or leadership needs a view spanning multiple administrators.
Consider a county that has worked with three administrators over ten years.
Each administrator may have used different reporting formats, location codes, or descriptions for similar claims. Historical attachments may be stored separately. Older claims may remain with a previous administrator while a new TPA handles new losses.
When leadership asks for a ten-year view of costs by department, the risk manager may need to combine spreadsheets, reconcile categories, and locate supporting records before the analysis can begin.
Maintaining an independent claims management system can make that work more manageable. With appropriate data mapping and validation, records from different administrators can support a more complete view of the organization’s history.
That history should remain valuable as service providers change.
Mobile Reporting Starts Where the Incident Happens
The quality of claims and incident information begins with the initial report.
An employee or supervisor reporting from a phone at a job site, facility, or accident location can capture details while they are fresh. Photos, incident descriptions, and supporting information give the people reviewing the event a better starting point.
Mobile reporting can also route information promptly to Risk Management, Safety, and other designated staff so investigations and follow-up can begin.
That initial report can support several needs:
- Notifying the TPA when a claim needs to be reported.
- Starting an internal investigation.
- Documenting a hazard or unsafe condition.
- Coordinating case management and return-to-work activity.
- Recording incidents that require internal attention even when no claim is established.
Capturing information once and routing it to the appropriate people can help create a more consistent process from the initial incident through investigation, claims administration, and follow-up.
Does That Mean Entering Everything Twice?
This is a reasonable question—and one to address when designing the workflow.
Using an internal RMIS doesn’t have to mean entering the same incident into two systems. The options depend on what the TPA accepts and how the client and administrator agree to exchange information.
Some TPAs accept initial reports generated by an organization’s RMIS. Other arrangements support electronic file transfers or integrations. The RMIS can serve as the primary point of entry for the incident, with information sent to the administrator through the agreed process.
An agreed workflow could involve:
- A supervisor submits an incident through the organization’s RMIS using a phone.
- Designated staff review the report and supply any additional required information.
- The report is sent to the TPA through its accepted process.
- The TPA establishes the claim and returns agreed information, such as the claim number, status, payments, and reserves.
At Recordables, we work with clients and their TPAs to establish reporting processes that can reduce duplicate entry, including arrangements where administrators accept initial reports. Some TPAs require their own portal or additional entry, so you can’t assume you can eliminate duplicate typing. Discuss intake requirements early, identify which system maintains each part of the record, and agree on how updates will move between them.
Clients should advocate for a process that supports their operational needs. Asking whether the TPA will accept a report from the organization’s RMIS is a practical place to start.
What Happens When You Change TPAs?
Changing administrators requires planning for information accumulated over years of claims activity.
Before a transition, organizations should ask:
- Will we retain access to both open and closed claim records?
- Does the export include notes, payment transactions, reserves, and attachments—or only summary information?
- What formats are available, and can another system use them?
- Are file layouts and mapping instructions available to simplify validation?
- Are there export costs or deadlines for retrieving records?
- How will we receive updates to claims retained by the previous administrator?
A spreadsheet containing claim numbers and total costs may be useful, but it may not provide enough detail for future analysis or everyday work.
Having the files is only part of the process. Being able to trust and use the information is just as important.
One administrator may identify a department as “Public Works,” while another uses “PW.” A facility may have been renamed. Claim categories may differ between systems.
Without reconciliation, reports can split related records into separate groups or produce misleading comparisons. These inconsistencies can also weaken predictive analysis and AI-generated findings.
A sound conversion process should include reviewing field definitions, mapping categories, checking record counts, and reconciling financial totals. Ongoing transfers need clear responsibilities for reviewing errors and resolving discrepancies.
Historical and current data become more useful when their meaning remains consistent.
A Stronger Partnership With Your TPA
An internal risk management system can support a productive relationship with your administrator while giving your organization a broader view of risk.
The TPA continues handling its assigned claims responsibilities. Your organization can connect that claims activity with safety, case management, inspections, internally managed incidents, and leadership reporting.
Agreeing on intake, data exchanges, and responsibilities helps reduce unnecessary work and gives both parties more dependable information.
A TPA relationship may change. Your ability to understand your organization’s history—and use it to manage risk—should continue.
How Recordables Can Help
Recordables’ TrackComp® and TrackAbility® help organizations maintain and use workers’ compensation and liability claims information. TrackComp also supports safety, case management, and return-to-work activities. TrackAlytics® provides dashboards and analytical tools, while TrackAlert® can use AI within Recordables’ secure environment to analyze historical data, identify emerging risks, predict potential outcomes, and recommend actions to support better decisions. With experience in historical data conversion and TPA data exchanges, Recordables works with clients to define practical reporting and integration processes that support continuity and reduce unnecessary entry.
To discuss your organization’s needs, schedule a personalized demo or call (312) 961-7894.

Paul Kofman, President of Recordables, has been providing software solutions in Risk Management, Claims Management, Disability Management, Safety, and Occupational for more than 30 years.